top of page

Bad Radiator Cap or Head Gasket? (How to Tell)

When it comes to vehicle maintenance, it's important to be able to diagnose and fix problems as they arise. One common issue that can cause problems with your car's cooling system is a bad radiator cap or a blown head gasket.


Both can lead to engine overheating and other issues, but it's important to know the difference so you can take the appropriate action.


The best way to tell the difference between a bad radiator cap or a head gasket issue is to see if there is coolant in the engine oil. If you can see a milky or frothy looking substance in the oil filler cap then it's likely the issue is a blown head gasket and not the radiator cap.


In this article, we'll go over the signs of a bad radiator cap or head gasket, as well as what these parts do and how to tell the issues apart.

 

Table of Contents:


person opening a radiator cap

Signs of a Bad Radiator Cap

Below are some of the common signs of a bad and faulty radiator cap.


  • Engine Overheating: A bad radiator cap can cause your engine to overheat. When the cap is not working properly, it can't create the proper seal to maintain the proper coolant pressure. This can lead to coolant leakage and reduced coolant flow to the engine, resulting in overheating.

  • Leaking and Low Coolant: A bad radiator cap can also cause coolant to leak from the system. If you notice coolant leaking from your car or if the coolant level in the reservoir is consistently low, it could be a sign of a bad radiator cap.

  • Overflowing Coolant Reservoir: If the coolant reservoir is overflowing, it could be a sign of a bad radiator cap. The cap is designed to release pressure in the system to prevent overflow. If it is not working properly, the pressure can build up and cause the coolant to overflow.

  • Burst or Collapsed Radiator Hoses: A bad radiator cap can also cause the hoses in your cooling system to burst or collapse. This can happen when the pressure in the system gets too high or isn't regulated properly, causing the hoses to expand or collapse and eventually fail.


What Does a Radiator Cap Do?

The radiator cap is a small but important part of your car's cooling system. It is located on top of the radiator and acts as a pressure relief valve. It is designed to maintain the proper pressure in the system and prevent coolant from boiling over.


It also prevents coolant from leaking from the system and helps to keep the coolant in the engine at the proper level.


a head gasket

Signs of a Blown Head Gasket

Below are some of the most common signs of a blown head gasket.


  • Engine Overheating: A blown head gasket can cause your engine to overheat for similar reasons as a bad radiator cap. The head gasket sits between the engine block and cylinder head and is responsible for sealing the coolant and oil passages. If it fails, it can allow coolant to leak into the oil passages and reduce coolant flow to the engine.

  • Milky and Contaminated Engine Oil: Another sign of a blown head gasket is if the oil in your engine looks milky or frothy. This is caused by coolant leaking into the oil passages and mixing with the oil. This can cause damage to the engine and lead to poor performance.

  • White Smoke From Exhaust: If you see white smoke coming from the exhaust, it could be a sign of a blown head gasket. When coolant leaks into the combustion chamber, it can cause white smoke to be emitted from the exhaust.

  • Poor Engine Performance: A blown head gasket can also cause poor engine performance. If the engine is not getting enough coolant, it can run poorly or stall. A blown head gasket has other effects on engine performance such as reduced fuel efficiency and power output.

  • Rough Engine Idle: A blown head gasket can also cause a rough idle.


What Does a Head Gasket Do?

The head gasket is a sealing component that sits between the engine block and the cylinder head. Its main function is to seal the combustion chamber and prevent coolant and engine oil from mixing. It also prevents combustion gases from leaking into the cooling system.


Bad Radiator Cap or Head Gasket?

As previously mentioned, a bad radiator cap and a blown head gasket can both cause similar symptoms, such as engine overheating and low coolant levels.


However, one of the most obvious ways to tell the difference between a bad radiator cap and head gasket is to check the engine oil. If the oil appears milky or frothy, it is likely that the head gasket is blown.


A head gasket usually presents with other issues such as white smoke coming from the exhaust and reduced engine performance.


How Do You Know if Your Radiator Cap Is Leaking?

One of the ways to check if the radiator cap is leaking is to inspect the coolant level and check for leaks. The coolant level should be between the "full" and "low" marks. If the level is low, it could indicate a leak.


Another way to check for a leak is to look for any puddles or drops of coolant under the vehicle, as well as any wetness or discoloration on the outside of the radiator cap. If the radiator cap is leaking, it will need to be replaced.


How Often Do Radiator Caps Need to Be Replaced?

Radiator caps are designed to last for a long time, but it is important to check them regularly for signs of wear and tear.


In general, it is a good idea to have the radiator cap inspected during regular vehicle maintenance, such as oil changes. If the radiator cap is showing signs of wear or damage, it should be replaced as soon as possible.


How Obvious Is a Blown Head Gasket?

A blown head gasket can be difficult to diagnose, especially if the symptoms are not obvious. Some of the symptoms, such as engine overheating and poor engine performance, can also be caused by other issues.


However, if the engine oil appears milky or frothy, it is a strong indication that the head gasket is blown. In addition, a compression test (using a compression tester) can help to determine whether the head gasket is blown.


Conclusion

In conclusion, a bad radiator cap and a blown head gasket are two important issues that can cause significant problems for a vehicle. It is important to be aware of the signs and symptoms of these issues so that they can be addressed as soon as possible.


If you suspect a problem with the radiator cap or head gasket, it is important to have your vehicle inspected by a professional mechanic. Regular vehicle maintenance, such as